• Home
  • About
    • Favorites
    • Contact
  • Shop
    • TPT Store
    • Amazon Favorites
    • LIKETOKNOW.IT
  • Blog
    • Back to School
    • Class Songs
    • End of Year
    • Holidays
    • Management
    • Student Engagement
    • Slides
    • Class Pet
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube

Mrs. Munch's Munchkins

A blog to give teachers ideas and tools that make teaching easier

December 22, 2021

Save your Sanity: Try the Pencil Challenge!

Tired of finding pencils on the floor, hidden in the back of desks, and disappearing in droves? If so, The Great Pencil Challenge is a solution for YOU!

What if I told you your students were capable of keeping the SAME pencil for THREE weeks or more?! Don’t believe me? My class of 25 second graders were able to do it, so I know your students can, too! Read below for how you can start your first “Great Pencil Challenge.”

What is the Great Pencil Challenge?

The Great Pencil Challenge (we’ll call it GPC for short,) challenges students to keep the same pencil for a set duration of time. Students who succeed earn a small reward.

Prefer to watch than read?! Check out the YouTube video below!

Challenge Set Up

First, give each student in your class their own new pencil, designated with taped on numbers or name flags. Write names or numbers directly on the pencil with permanent marker if preferred. Personally, I like using the taped flags because they make the pencils easier to find.

Additionally, ask students to clear out any old pencils in your classroom. The first time I did this, a student had eight pencils hiding in the back of their desk. Yes, EIGHT!

Next, set a time limit for the challenge. If you’re trying a challenge for the first time, use 1-2 weeks as a starting point. This will help you assess how capable your students are before you decide to add on time.

After that, name your reward. In my room, the reward remains the same time after time (with the exception of the final challenge.) This keeps things simple and avoids the need for me to “out do” myself on the reward time after time. The reward is always 10 class dojo points or “Dojo Dollars” as we call them. Students spend their dojos on class rewards such as “Stinky Feet” (no shoes in class for the day) and “Lunch with the Teacher.”

The Rules

Now its time to set your GPC rules! Present these at the start of the challenge so all students are on the same page. Below I’ll tell you the rules I use with my 2nd graders. Of course, you’ll want to edit the rules to fit your age group and style.

  • Pencils can only be sharpened in the electric sharpener at the end of the day (*exception if the tip breaks off)
  • Mrs. Munch and the student entitled the class job of “Pencil Sharpener” are the only two people who may sharpen pencils with the electric sharpener.
  • Pencils may be sharpened with a personal sharpener at any time.
  • Broken pencils are disqualified (*exception if a peer steps/breaks the pencil.)
  • Pencils that are too short to legibly write with are disqualified.
  • When students lose their pencil, they must first search on their own by taking EVERYTHING out of their desk (it’s almost always in the desk or supply box.) If not found, Mrs. Munch will either help them look or give them a pencil to borrow if its not a fitting time to search.
  • If an appropriate time, Mrs. Munch may request the class helps search for one minute help find the lost pencil before it is called out. If found, the pencil is still in.
  • Pencils found after being called “out” are still out.
  • Students help one another keep track of their pencil. Any student hiding another student’s pencil will be called out. The other student involved is still in the challenge.
  • Mrs. Munch may choose to “pause” the challenge at any time for a test or learning activity. We will not search for lost pencils during this time. Mrs. Munch will provide an alternate pencil to use. Once the “pause” is lifted, the challenge resumes as normal.

The Buy In

So, now you’re on board. You understand the challenge and are ready to introduce it to your students. But, will they buy in? I can tell you wholeheartedly, my experience is YES! In every class I’ve had, students have been excited and eager to compete in the GPC. However, there are things I do to ensure this kind of engagement. Below are some pointers:

  1. SET THE STAGE: Create hype by showing excitement as you explain the premise. For example, “I have a new challenge for you, are you ready to hear it?!” Drum up the timeline and the reward as you explain further.

2. SET THEM UP TO WIN: Students rise to the level of our BELIEF in them. Tell them you know a class of 2nd graders (aka mine!) that went three whole weeks and you KNOW they can too. Start small if you need to (do a one week or even one DAY challenge if that’s what you need!)

3. HELP WHEN NEEDED: Go over desk organization, systems for where to place your pencil, and tips for finding it when lost. In our class, the first thing we do is check our art box and then pull everything out of our desk (I’d say it has an 80% success rate.) Assist those who need a little extra help by checking in with them more often, helping them look when their pencil is lost, etc.

4. USE THE GOOD PENCILS: Make the challenge easier for students by using quality pencils! You know the kind. I especially love using Ticonderoga pencils. They sharpened easily and are extremely durable. Though wonderful, these pencils can be expensive. Ask classroom families and friends to donate a pack to get you started.

What if it’s too Challenging?

I’ve been doing this challenge for four years. In that time, I’ve had MANY students with unique needs and many who have struggled with organization. In spite of those hindrances, ALL my students have been successful with the challenge! And not only success, but repeated success.

It is truly rare that the same student gets “out” of the challenge more than once during the year. Many are able to say in every challenge!

Conversely, it is called a challenge for a reason. Not every student will win every time and that’s ok. Valuable life lessons are learned when we lose! Make your classroom a safe place to experience this. Don’t be afraid of emotions or try to limit them. Losing can be hard. Comfort your students who may struggle with loss and guide them through.

One thing that has helped my students is knowing they can try again. Because we do challenges year round, they know there will be a next one. Even students with amazing organizational skills lose their pencil sometimes. Encourage students in their effort and remind them everyone loses. Share an example of a time you lost if appropriate.

Keep Spirits High

At the end of the challenge, celebrate the victories! Before handing out the reward, congratulate all students on their hard work and effort in the challenge. After all, the main goal of the challenge is for students to give their best effort into keeping track of their pencil. This simultaneously solves pencil problems in class and brings a fun energy into the room.

Certainly, we want all students to be successful. But, they may not all reach success within the same challenge. Thus, I choose to hand out the reward discreetly to avoid students feeling left out if they did not win that challenge. For example, when award the “Dojo Dollars,” it is done at the end of the day after students have left. Students who won the challenge know they earned 10 Dojo Dollars, but we don’t make a big show about it. They simply see it reflected in their account next time they buy rewards.

Finally, before beginning a new challenge, assess the last. I’ve found if 85% or more students were successful, we’re ready to extend the next challenge. If our percentage is lower than this, I keep the length of the challenge the same for the next round. Our class is currently working at four week challenges!

Something to Help…

To conclude, let me make your life even easier. I’ve created tracking sheets and Google slides to use in your classroom that will make starting the challenge a breeze! Display the slides in class to introduce the challenge, and use the tracking pages to help with management throughout its entirety. The Great Pencil Challenge Guide provides visuals and additional tips (not found in this blog) to navigate you every step of the day. Click here to get more information!

Other posts you might enjoy:

  • The Magic of Classroom Songs
  • 4 Ways to Spice Up your Math Block
  • My Journey to Teaching

Filed in: Blog Posts, Management, Student Engagement | 1 Comment

Comments

  1. Tatiana

    January 1, 2022 at 8:55 pm

    Amazing! I can not wait to have a go!🤩

    Loading...
    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

A photo of the author of the website. Teacher expert, Melody Munch.

About me

Hi teacher friend! My name is Melody Munch. I taught 2nd grade for 8 years and am currently serving teachers through full time resource creation. Here you'll find ideas to help you create classroom memories and teach with ease. Enjoy looking around, I’m so happy you're here!

an envelope
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Search the Blog

Pinterest Board

Popular Posts

How to Create a SPECTACULAR Classroom Balloon Parade!

Ready for one of the most memorable weeks of the school year?! This is one of my favorite November activities, and because of that, I am walking you through exactly how to bring the magic of the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade into your own classroom. From learning about the parade to balloon design, building floats, […]

Advice for Parent Teacher Conferences

Conferences + Teachers = Anxiety. True for you?! While preparing and hosting Parent Teacher Conferences can be very stressful, there are a few things you can do to add ease to this time and help them run smoothly. Read for my tips below!

Make Your Classroom Christmas Party Easy and Stress-Free

Have you ever spent weeks planning a classroom Christmas party only to watch it turn into complete chaos the moment it starts? Students finish activities in two minutes. Others are wandering. Parents are not sure what to do. And somehow you are trying to manage ALL of it while also actually enjoying the moment with […]

A teacher holding out a booklet that reads "Holidays Around the World"

Teach Holidays Around the World in the Most Exciting Way!

Have you ever wished you could take your students on a trip around the world? No passport required. No permission slips, no airport delays. Just your classroom, a little curiosity, and a holidays around the world adventure that students will not stop talking about. That is exactly what this unit makes possible. And the best […]

Follow @mrsmunchsmunchkins

mrsmunchsmunchkins

🍎 Here to help Elementary Teachers
🫶🏼Jesus lover, wife, & mama
📓Creating for the classroom full time
⬇️ Find items from posts linked below

Students were INVESTED in this one 😅🦃 Comment TURK Students were INVESTED in this one 😅🦃 Comment TURKEY for the link to the game!

The day before break can be tricky for keeping students engaged…but not when saving a turkey is involved! Students had so much fun with this and used their math skills every step of the way. 🧡

In my 2nd grade classroom, I liked pairing students up so they could work together to solve each problem. We used whiteboards and notebooks for solving the problems. I walked around to assist groups as needed. In most cases, everyone succeeded in saving Trina! Students felt so accomplished. 👏🏼👏🏼

This is the PERFECT last minute Thanksgiving game because it requires ZERO prep. Students will just need access to a device to play! A Google account is not required.

I hope you LOVE playing with your class! 

#teachersofinstagram #elementaryteacher #teacherideas #2ndgradeteacher #3rdgradeteacher
Let’s make the board more festive🎄❤️ Comment SLIDE Let’s make the board more festive🎄❤️ Comment SLIDES for the link!

These are so fun for the Christmas season! I also offer a Winter themed set for those who need/prefer that. ❄️

#teachersofinstagram #elementaryteacher #2ndgradeteacher #1stgradeteacher #3rdgradeteacher
This isn’t an ordinary elf…it’s BETTER 🤩👏🏼🎄 Commen This isn’t an ordinary elf…it’s BETTER 🤩👏🏼🎄 Comment COUNTDOWN for the links!

I promise you, this little tradition will become something you look forward to every year! Weave kindness into your days before break and keep students excited to walk on every morning. ❤️

I have a Winter themed version of this, too! ❄️I’ll send you both links when you comment “Countdown.” 

#teachersofinstagram #classroomideas #2ndgradeteacher #3rdgradeteacher #elementaryteacher
Your new favorite classroom tradition: the Kindnes Your new favorite classroom tradition: the Kindness Snowman! ☃️ Students love this festive countdown!

During the 12 days before Winter Break ❄️ two things happen each day:

1) Students get a Gift from the Teacher: These are small, often free or inexpensive things for the class to look forward to daily. Examples include writing with pens or bringing a stuffed animal!

2) They get a Kindness Challenge: brought by the “Kindness Snowman!” ☃️✨

This Snowman is not just any average Snowman, he is ❄️magical ❄️. He brings a note each day with a Kindness Challenge for the class to complete! This helps the class focus on the gift & joy of giving.🩵

If you’re looking for something simple to keep your class engaged & EXCITED to be at school every day until break-this is for YOU. 

Comment the word SNOWMAN to be sent this resource link! ☃️

Also available in a Christmas version (I’ll send you both links! 🎄)

#classroomideas #teacherideas #2ndgradeteacher #elementaryteacher #teachersofinstagram
Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2026 · Theme by Blog Pixie

%d